Application Indexing has Room for Improvement
Application discovery is a big problem. While search engines index the entirety of the web, making it fairly easy to find content most relevant to my search query, trying to discover applications that meet my needs is a bit more difficult. Where search engines utilize complex algorithms (see Google Page Rank) to determine importance of a page, searching through application indexes yield results that seem to be based on less sophisticated algorithms. Seeing as applications are, arguably, more complex than a web page, the discovery process should be more robust. Here are three ways that I think these indexes can improve application discoverability:
- Download count isn’t the only thing that matters: If there’s one common bond between app indexes on the web, it’s that download count (or user count) seems to have the greatest influence on the results rank. Ok, I get it; more users must mean it’s a better application, right? Sure, fair indicator, but it’s not the only thing that matters. Give me more ways to sort the results. How about the ability of the app to solve a user’s problem? How important is an app to a user? App indexes need to figure this out. Implied data is good, explicit data is better. Look at usage, user life, reviews/ranks. All of this information matters when showing me relevant quality results.
- Index Features: What if I’m looking for a particular feature in an application? Right now I am limited to two behaviors: One, download the app, see if it has the feature(s) I’m looking for, and uninstall if it doesn’t. Rinse and repeat. Two, navigate out of the index to the app site, try to find a feature list and make a decision from there. Features need to be clearly identified and meticulously indexed so my decision making process can be streamlined. Think of application indexes being a “decision engine”, just like Bing.
- Eliminate the Techie Skew: Two of the main app indexes out there (Wakoopa and Software.Informer) require a user to install an application that indexes and then tracks your applications and their usage. But, let’s face it, the users that download these apps are skewed as techie users. While I consider myself a techie, I know there are other app user personas out there and that relevancy can only be improved by ensuring all apps get a fair representation from all constituents. These indexing services need mass appeal to provide a service that truly encompasses the world of apps.
App indexes are moving in the right direction towards solving the problem of application discovery. I visit these sites regularly because it’s amazing to see what the thriving world of apps looks like when it’s indexed. There is room for improvement, however. Indexes like these should, and undoubtedly will, become better at enabling users to discover what apps will best solve their problems. And don’t get me wrong, it’s no easy task; indexing applications and their related attributes is not like indexing web pages. It’s not like you can pull a standardized feature set right out of an app; much of this information is crowd-sourced. But it must improve; the discovery process needs to be more relevant, higher quality and more streamlined. There needs to be a “killer app” of app indexes.
Eric Montag, Product Manager, W3i Holdings, LLC
Eric uses his experience in graphic design, mobile, and internet marketing to lead the charge in product research, planning, and execution, from both a consumer and business standpoint.
About W3i
If you need help with increasing distribution, revenue, or engagement for your Windows applications, contact us. W3i has over nine years experience with over 250 million installations. App marketers join W3i’s Application Network to grow their application companies.

functionality with Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, and LinkedIn integration. Oh yeah, their app supports email notifications, as well — pretty cool. The newest version of the
stop seeing themselves as RSS aggregators by taking a hint from 